GEPR HOME >Low Potentiality of Health Damage by the Fukushima Accident - from the survey of the atomic bomb survivors in Hiroshima and Nagasaki

Low Potentiality of Health Damage by the Fukushima Accident − from the survey of the atomic bomb survivors in Hiroshima and Nagasaki

Takaaki Ishii Fellow of Agora InstituteView PDF

The medical research of survivors from the atomic bombs in Hiroshima and Nagasaki has been used by governments to plan policies on national health care or radiation restrictions. This research surveys 280,000 people over 50 years. There is no similar case to this large scale medical research on radiation exposure.

With references to Emeritus Professor of Oxford University, Wade Allison’s "Radiation and Reason" [1], and a research article of Radiation Effects Research Foundation (Hiroshima: RERF) [2], I will introduce the fact that health hazards are hardly observed among atomic bomb survivors who were exposed to low-dose radiation.

Backgrounds of Research

From the research by RERF, we can grasp facts as fellows. When the atomic bombs were dropped, the numbers of total population of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were 429,000 people. Due to its heat and radiation, more than 103,000 were killed instantly. Although there are lack of right information after the explosion, there are medical records of 283,000 survivors since 1950.

From the record, from 1950 to 2000, 7.9% of the total population at the time of atomic bombs droppings, died from cancer, and among them, 0.4% is estimated to have died from cancer caused by radiation. This ratio is less than what was previously assumed. RERF also estimated the approximate amount of exposure of each 87,000 persons. They are estimated from behavioral data and health examination of each person.

RERF also predicted numbers of leukemia and cancer by using LNT hypothesis and medical data of Japanese who were not exposed. LNT hypothesis (linear no threshold: LNT)) means that radiation is harmful, even a small dose, and the degree of susceptibility to cancer is proportional to the amount of radiation exposed.

The Results of the Survey

Figure 1 and 2 shows number of deaths of the atomic bomb survivors by leukemia and cancer, from 1950 until 2000. The death by leukemia for people who were exposed to over 200 millisievert (mSv), and by cancer over 100mSv is more than it had been expected. We cannot observe health hazard under 100mSv.

Policies makers and health care professionals take these results as important references that show small possibility of health hazards by low-dose exposure, and the threshold is about 100mSv.

There is no report that the public exposure is over 100mSv by the Fukushima nuclear power plants accident. We can estimate that the potential for health damage caused by this accident is very small from the experience of Atomic bombs survivors.References:
[1] Wade Allison, 'Radiation and Reason', 2010
[2] Dale L. Preston, et al. 'Effect of Recent Changes in Atomic Bomb Survivor Dosimetry on Cancer Mortality Risk Estimates' RADIATION RESEARCH 162, 377-389, 2004.

(Figure 1) The number of people who died from leukemia among atomic bomb survivors from 1950 to 2000
Range of Exposure(mSv) Survivors Death(Actual) (Predicted)
Less than 5 37403 92 84.9
5-100 30387 69 72.1
100-200 5841 14 14.5
200-500 6304 27 15.6
500-1000 3963 20 9.5
1000-2000 1972 39 4.9
Over 2000 737 25 1.6
Total 86955 296 203
From Allison and RERF
(Figure 2) The number of people who died from cancer among atomic bomb survivors from 1950 to 2000
Range of Exposure(mSv) Survivors Death(Actual) (Predicted)
Less than 5 38507 4270 4282
5-100 29960 3387 3313
100-200 5949 732 691
200-500 6380 815 736
500-1000 3426 483 378
1000-2000 1764 326 191
Over 2000 625 114 56
Total 86611 10127 9647
From Allison and RERF

Video

Is Fukushima Dangerous? -- Distorted images of Japan - Morley Robertson × Nobuo Ikeda

What's happen? What was the cause in Fukushima? Morley Robertson, writer and DJ, talk about distorted images of Japan after Fukushima nuclear plant accident with Nobuo Ikeda.

21st Century Energy Challenges

At the ARPA-E 2012 summit, Bill Gates and U.S. Energy Secretary Steven Chu discussed the largest energy challenges of the 21st century in the U.S. and around the world.

A Web-TV Program "Is radiation really so harmful? Considering risks of nuclear power generation" (Japanese only)

Agora Institute, who operates GEPR, broadcasted a Web-TV program "Is radiation really so harmful? Considering risks of nuclear power generation" on internet video streaming channel "Niconico Live " on January 19th (in Japanese only) . Nobuo Ikeda, President of Agora Incorporated, and three experts on radiation, risk analysis, and energy policy discussed about the situations after Fukushima nuclear accident. Their opinions were consistent that potentiality of health damage caused by the Fukushima accident is very small. GEPR will provide a summary about this program soon.

Podcast

Agora Inc., who operates GEPR, releases a podcast program which was originally aired on Jan. 19th, 2012on internet video streaming channel "Nico-nico Live"; "Is radiation really so harmful? Considering risks of nuclear power generation" (Japanese only) The panel: Nobuo Ikeda, Akihiro Sawa, Jun Takada, and Hiroyuki Matsuda

Search

TWITTER

RSS

GEPR RSS